The Council for Boys and Young Men Research

By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies for the purpose of visitor statistics

The Council for Boys and Young Men^® Research

The Council utilizes the evidence-based strategies of motivational interviewing and strengths-based facilitation practices.

To read more about how these strategies provide a culturally responsive, trauma-informed approach to working with boys and young men, read more (PDF).

Cornell Study

Cornell Evaluation Shows Efficacy in Some Outcomes: Cornell University's ACT for Youth Adolescent Health Unit and New York State's Department of Health received a grant from the CDC to evaluate the efficacy of One Circle Foundation's Brothers As Allies curriculum for early adolescent males in diverse, socioeconomically disadvantaged communities to reduce risk for future sexual violence perpetration, between 2016 and 2021. While the covid-19 pandemic brought the study to a halt, some key outcomes were considered effective. Read the full article at Cornell Chronicle.

From Time 1 to Time 2, compared to the youth in the control groups, participants in The Council for Boys and Young Men's Brothers As Allies groups showed:

– Higher reports of victimization. This finding may reflect broader awareness of sexual aggression and violence as a result of program participation.

– Lower sexual violence perpetration

– Lower reported sexual harassment of others

– More likely to tell someone how they feel

– Less likely to call someone “homo” or “gay” if they thought the person was gay

View more information on these findings (PDF).

One Circle Foundation looks forward to continuing collaborations with partners to evaluate effectiveness of our Circle models to provide greater protection, connection and support to all youth.

Evaluation and Outcomes

The Council for Boys and Young Men^® has been evaluated in two studies and additional analyses through Portland State University, OR, by a team of doctorate, masters’ level, and undergraduate students and under the direction of Eric Mankowski, PhD, Associate Professor, Applied Social & Community Psychology, Department of Psychology.

The first study, in 2008, involved five organizations and 93 total participants, in middle schools, diversion programs, and probation. The study found:

Significant increases in boys' School Engagement. Self-efficacy related to Educational Goals and Avoiding Fights, Ethnic Pride and Conflict Skills were moving in the expected direction after 10 weeks.

Satisfaction Surveys revealed high satisfaction on average of participants in The Council programs.

View the Evaluation Poster or Phase One Final Report.

This study of The Council within the Ohio Department of Youth Services correctional settings in 2009-2010 found no changes in comparison of experimental and control groups. On careful analysis, however, the study detected significant demographic differences and pre-survey differences between groups such that a true comparison of changes was effectively more difficult to demonstrate.

View The Council Phase II Evaluation Final Report.

Another analysis of this study looked at The Council’s impact on Masculinity Beliefs for Diverse Youth in a Correctional Setting. The report showed that while traditional masculinity beliefs, strongly associated to risk behaviors, increased for all youth in the prison setting, those who participated in The Council programs for more weeks showed:

Significantly lower rates of increase in unhealthy beliefs about being male. This is important because of the apparent impact of The Council to slow the trend toward the limiting “boy code” – don’t feel, be tough, dominate others, always be in control, never express fear, etc.- that affects boys’ behaviors, relationships, and futures.

View the Brief Description of this report. View this Full report on masculinity beliefs and The Council.

Other data:

We welcome data reports from outside organizations!

OPBI is a nonprofit organization in Tampa, FL, which implemented The Council program to boys in middle schools, within classroom settings. They saw significant increases in boys’ school adjustment, and decreases in aggression rates. View OPBI’s 2007-2008 data summary.

Evaluate The Council at Your Agency

The Council Evaluation Packet, FREE in PDF format

The Council for Boys and Young Men^® Evaluation Tool Kit is available at no charge for your program evaluation! Includes instructions, forms, and public domain scales as well as author-permitted scales for The Council program evaluation. The scales are recommended by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), Center for Substance Abuse Prevention (CSAP), National Center for School Engagement, and scholars interested in measuring boys' attitudes and behaviors, especially related to risk and protective behaviors associated with violence prevention, substance abuse prevention, and interpersonal skills.

Outcomes: school engagement, caring and cooperation, substance abuse, masculinity beliefs, respecting differences, ethnic pride, respecting boundaries, and satisfaction.

For further information about research and evaluation of your Council program, please contact us at info@onecirclefoundation.org or call us at (415) 419-5119.